Click Judge name for a full evaluation.
Supreme Court
| Justice | Recommendation | Results |
|---|---|---|
| Serna, Patricio M. | Retain |
Retained |
Court of Appeals
| Judge | Recommendation | Results |
|---|---|---|
| Sutin, Jonathan B | Retain |
Retained |
District Court
| Judge | District | Recommendation | Results |
|---|---|---|---|
| Garcia, Tim L. | 1 | Retain |
Retained |
| Hall, James | 1 | Retain |
Retained |
| Ortiz, Raymond Z. | 1 | Retain |
Retained |
| Pfeffer, Stephen D. | 1 | Retain |
Retained |
| Sanchez, Daniel | 1 | Retain |
Retained |
| Vigil, Barbara J. | 1 | Retain |
Retained |
| Vigil, Michael Edward | 1 | Retain |
Retained |
| Baca, Ted C. | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Baca, Theresa M. | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Barela-Shepherd, Denise | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Butkus, Carl J. | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Campbell, Clay Pace | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Candelaria, Neil C. | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Huling, Valerie A. | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Jewell, Angela J. | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Lang, William F. | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Martinez, Kenneth H. | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Murdoch, Albert S. "Pat" | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Nash, Nan G. | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Rivera, Geraldine E. | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Romero, Jr., John J. | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Sanchez, Ross C. | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Vanzi, Linda M. | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Walker, Deborah Davis | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Whitaker, Stan | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Zamora, M. Monica | 2 | Retain |
Retained |
| Bridgforth, Stephen | 3 | Retain |
Retained |
| Driggers, Douglas R. | 3 | Retain |
Retained |
| Macias, Fernando R. | 3 | Retain |
Retained |
| Martin, Jim T. | 3 | Retain |
Retained |
| Murphy, Mike | 3 | Retain |
Retained |
| Robles, Robert E. | 3 | Retain |
Retained |
| Schultz, Lisa Claire | 3 | Retain |
Retained |
| Valentine, Jerald A. | 3 | Retain |
Retained |
| Aragon, Abigail S. | 4 | Retain |
Retained |
| Mathis, Eugenio S. | 4 | Retain |
Retained |
| Bell, Steven L. | 5 | Retain |
Retained |
| Clingman, Gary L. | 5 | Retain |
Retained |
| Currier, III, Charles C. | 5 | Retain |
Retained |
| Gray, Jane Shuler | 5 | Retain |
Retained |
| Maddox, Don | 5 | Retain |
Retained |
| Romero, Freddie J. | 5 | Retain |
Retained |
| Rutledge, Thomas A. | 5 | Insufficient Time In Office |
Retained |
| Shamas, Ralph D. | 5 | Retain |
Retained |
| Jeffreys, Gary M. | 6 | Retain |
Retained |
| Quintero, Vidalia R. | 6 | Retain |
Retained |
| Robinson, J.C. | 6 | Retain |
Retained |
| Kase, III, Edmund H. | 7 | Retain |
Retained |
| Reynolds, Matthew G. | 7 | Retain |
Retained |
| Sweazea, Kevin R. | 7 | Retain |
Retained |
| Paternoster, John M. | 8 | Retain |
Retained |
| Sanchez, Sam B. | 8 | Retain |
Retained |
| Hartley, Teddy L. | 9 | Retain |
Retained |
| Orlik, Robert S. | 9 | Retain |
Retained |
| Quinn, Stephen K. | 9 | Retain |
Retained |
| Reeb, Jr., David P. | 9 | Retain |
Retained |
| Aragon, Robert A. | 11 | Retain |
Retained |
| Birdsall, William C. | 11 | Retain |
Retained |
| Dean, Jr., John A. | 11 | Retain |
Retained |
| DePauli, Jr., Louis E. | 11 | Retain |
Retained |
| Foutz, Grant L. | 11 | Retain |
Retained |
| Hynes, Thomas J. | 11 | Retain |
Retained |
| Price, Sandra A. | 11 | Retain |
Retained |
| Townsend, Karen L. | 11 | Retain |
Retained |
| Counts, James Waylon | 12 | Retain |
Retained |
| Parsons, Karen L. | 12 | Retain |
Retained |
| Ritter, Jr., Jerry H. | 12 | Retain |
Retained |
| Davis, John F. | 13 | Retain |
Retained |
| Eichwald, George P. | 13 | Retain |
Retained |
| McDonald, Louis P. | 13 | Retain |
Retained |
| Olguin, Camille E. | 13 | Retain |
Retained |
| Otero, Violet C. | 13 | Retain |
Retained |
| Pope, John W. | 13 | No Opinion |
Retained |
| Sanchez, William Bill | 13 | Retain |
Retained |
Metropolitan Court (Bernalillo County)
Judges not evaluated this year.*
* Not all judges stand for retention in every election. Supreme Court justices and NM Court of Appeals judges stand for retention when their staggered terms expire. In 2021, the New Mexico Legislature passed a law changing the terms of evaluation for District Court and Metropolitan Court judges. For information on these changes, see the IMPORTANT NOTICE TO VOTERS on the home page of this website.